Brokerage Transfer Bonuses

Cash bonuses for transferring taxable, IRA, and retirement brokerage assets — with the holding period, ACATS basics, and 1099-MISC tax treatment stated up front.

Brokerage transfer bonuses pay you to move existing investment assets from one brokerage to another. Unlike checking bonuses, the qualifying behavior isn't a direct deposit — it's a successful ACATS transfer (Automated Customer Account Transfer Service) of in-kind positions or cash above a threshold, followed by a holding period during which the assets must remain at the new brokerage. Bonus tiers typically scale with the asset amount transferred.

ACATS is the industry-standard mechanism for moving brokerage accounts between firms. The receiving brokerage initiates the transfer; the sending brokerage validates and releases the positions. Standard transfers settle in five to ten business days, though delays are common. Mutual funds, illiquid assets, and proprietary money market funds may not transfer in-kind and may need to be liquidated first — a step that can have tax consequences in taxable accounts. ACATS does not move cost-basis history reliably in every case; verify it after the transfer and request a basis transfer if needed.

Holding periods on brokerage bonuses are longer than on checking — commonly six to twelve months, sometimes twenty-four. Early-departure clauses typically either claw back the bonus or simply void it if it hasn't yet posted. The bonus itself is generally treated as miscellaneous income and reported on Form 1099-MISC by the receiving brokerage; tax treatment is summarized in our tax implications guide.

Live offers

How we evaluate brokerage transfer offers

We compare brokerage offers on three measures. First, the headline bonus as a percentage of the assets being transferred — useful for comparing tiers across brokerages. Second, the all-in cost: ACATS fees charged by the outgoing broker (commonly $50–$100, sometimes reimbursed by the receiving broker), any partial-share liquidations that trigger taxable events, and bid-ask spreads on positions that have to be sold and rebought. Third, the time-friction estimate: transfers that go cleanly take a week; transfers that hit a snag on cost basis, restricted securities, or operational mismatches can take a month of intermittent attention.

For tax-advantaged accounts, an additional concern is whether the bonus is paid into the IRA (preserving its tax-deferred or tax-free character) or to a linked taxable account (triggering ordinary income). Both structures exist; the difference materially affects after-tax value.

Recapture clauses get a careful read. The standard pattern is that closing the account or transferring assets out before the holding period ends voids unpaid bonuses and may claw back paid bonuses pro rata. Verify the precise mechanism and the exact end-date.

What makes a brokerage transfer offer worth pursuing

The math typically favors larger transfers. A 1% bonus on $25,000 is $250 — net of taxes, probably not worth the friction. The same 1% on $250,000 is $2,500, which usually clears the friction threshold by a wide margin. Tier breakpoints are where the value lives; pushing a transfer into a higher tier with a top-up deposit can change the economics meaningfully.

Beyond the bonus, evaluate the receiving brokerage on its merits as a long-term home for the assets. Bonuses paid to move money to a brokerage with worse fees, worse execution, or worse research is a lossy long-term trade. The hold period locks you in for the stated months; you may end up choosing to stay longer.

For IRAs specifically, the trustee-to-trustee transfer path preserves the account's tax character automatically. The 60-day rollover path is also available but carries the once-per-12-month limit and the risk of withholding if mishandled. See our IRA transfer page for the IRA-specific mechanics.